| Year | Winning Team | Score | Runner-up | Score | Venue |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1911 | University | 14.15 | Glenferrie | 5.11 | University Oval |
| 1912 | University | 12.9 | St. Francis Xavier | 5.11 | University Oval |
| 1913 | Kingswood | 5.8 | Semaphore Central | 4.6 | – |
| 1914 | Semaphore Central | 6.12 | University | 4.11 | Norwood Oval |
| 1915 | Kingswood | 8.11 | Semaphore Central | 5.11 | – |
| 1916-1919 | Suspended due to war | – | – | – | – |
| 1920 | University | 10.18 | Henley and Grange | 2.11 | – |
| 1921 | University | 9.1 | Prospect | 7.11 | – |
| 1922 | University | 9.9 | Semaphore Central | 8.4 | – |
| 1923 | Semaphore Central | 6.1 | University | 5.5 | Norwood Oval |
| 1924 | Semaphore Central | 6.1 | Teachers Training College | 5.9 | Norwood Oval |
| 1925 | Semaphore Central | 9.16 | Kenilworth | 7.6 | Norwood Oval |
| 1926 | University | 9.15 | Semaphore Central | 7.18 | Norwood Oval |
| 1927 | Kenilworth | 10.18 | University | 10.9 | Belair National Park |
| 1928 | Semaphore Central | 10.13 | Kenilworth | 4.11 | Thebarton Oval |
| 1929 | University | 11.11 | Semaphore Central | 10.1 | Jubilee Oval |
| 1930 | Kenilworth | 12.15 | University | 12.13 | Glenelg Oval |
| 1931 | Semaphore Central | 12.11 | Underdale United | 9.16 | University Oval |
| 1932 | University | 14.11 | Underdale United | 11.13 | Jubilee Oval |
| 1933 | Underdale United | 6.15 | University | 6.1 | Thebarton Oval |
| 1934 | Underdale United | 11.11 | University | 8.11 | Norwood Oval |
| 1935 | St. Peter’s Old Collegians | 13.8 | Underdale United | 10.13 | Unley Oval |
| 1936 | West Adelaide United | 11.19 | Underdale United | 10.8 | Thebarton Oval |
| 1937 | West Adelaide United | 10.3 | Prince Alfred Old Collegians | 7.1 | Prospect Oval |
| 1938 | Semaphore Central | 14.12 | Underdale United | 10.1 | Alberton Oval |
| 1939 | Exeter | 15.11 | Payneham | 15.9 | Prospect Oval |
| 1940 | Exeter | 11.11 | Semaphore Central | 5.12 | Alberton Oval |
| 1941 | Exeter | 10.16 | SA Railways Institute | 8.6 | Woodville Oval |
| 1942-1945 | Suspended due to war | – | – | – | – |
| 1946 | Woodville | 8.13 | University | 9.5 | Alberton Oval |
| 1947 | Exeter | 14.14 | Woodville | 6.8 | Alberton Oval |
| 1948 | Exeter | 8.1 | Semaphore Central | 6.8 | Woodville Oval |
| 1949 | Semaphore Central | 8.11 | University | 4.1 | Alberton Oval |
| 1950 | Walkerville | 5.12 | Exeter | 6.3 | Thebarton Oval |
| 1951 | University | 6.8 | Exeter | 5.13 | Thebarton Oval |
| 1952 | University | 13.17 | Exeter | 10.7 | Thebarton Oval |
| 1953 | Walkerville | 8.1 | University | 7.8 | Alberton Oval |
| 1954 | University | 19.11 | Rosewater | 10.4 | Alberton Oval |
| 1955 | University | 18.5 | Exeter | 7.7 | Alberton Oval |
| 1956 | Semaphore Central | 11.8 | University | 6.1 | Payneham Oval |
| 1957 | Rosewater | 8.19 | Semaphore Central | 6.13 | Kensington Oval |
| 1958 | Riverside | 8.11 | University | 6.13 | Alberton Oval |
| 1959 | Semaphore Central | 15.1 | Riverside | 8.17 | Kensington Oval |
| 1960 | University | 6.4 | Semaphore Central | 2.6 | Alberton Oval |
| 1961 | University | 8.6 | Kilburn | 3.8 | Alberton Oval |
| 1962 | University | 8.14 | Teachers College | 7.5 | Alberton Oval |
| 1963 | Teachers College | 5.7 | University | 3.7 | Alberton Oval |
| 1964 | Payneham | 11.11 | University | 10.8 | Norwood Oval |
| 1965 | University | 14.15 | Riverside | 3.18 | Alberton Oval |
| 1966 | Teachers College | 9.11 | University | 3.7 | Alberton Oval |
| 1967 | Teachers College | 8.1 | University | 7.8 | Alberton Oval |
| 1968 | University | 9.1 | Teachers College | 6.5 | Alberton Oval |
| 1969 | Adelaide University | 7.8 | Teachers College | 4.7 | Alberton Oval |
| 1970 | Semaphore Central | 8.16 | Teachers College | 6.15 | Alberton Oval |
| 1971 | Teachers College | 15.16 | Seaton Ramblers | 8.14 | Alberton Oval |
| 1972 | Semaphore Central | 13.11 | Adelaide Teachers College | 13.9 | Alberton Oval |
| 1973 | Seaton Ramblers | 14.8 | Payneham | 10.6 | Alberton Oval |
| 1974 | Adelaide University | 16.11 | Payneham | 7.5 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1975 | Adelaide University | 14.15 | Flinders Park | 4.9 | Prospect Oval |
| 1976 | Flinders Park | 19.2 | Adelaide University | 10.12 | Richmond Oval |
| 1977 | Flinders Park | 9.13 | Semaphore Central | 5.14 | Richmond Oval |
| 1978 | Payneham | 12.2 | Glenunga | 9.8 | Richmond Oval |
| 1979 | Adelaide College | 18.13 | Broadview | 15.1 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1980 | Broadview | 17.12 | Adelaide College | 4.18 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1981 | Adelaide College | 7.14 | Riverside | 6.5 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1982 | Adelaide College | 16.1 | Riverside | 11.1 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1983 | Riverside | 15.7 | Adelaide University | 11.11 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1984 | Riverside | 14.15 | Greek | 11.14 | Norwood Oval |
| 1985 | Greek | 16.9 | Riverside | 11.11 | Alberton Oval |
| 1986 | Adelaide University | 11.17 | Riverside | 12.8 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1987 | Broadview | 12.6 | Greek Camden | 7.15 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1988 | Greenacres | 11.13 | Broadview | 11.11 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1989 | Broadview | 18.13 | Greek Camden | 2.8 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1990 | Greek Camden | 18.12 | Riverside | 12.15 | Alberton Oval |
| 1991 | Greek Camden | 9.12 | Kilburn | 9.1 | Alberton Oval |
| 1992 | Port District | 17.8 | Broadview | 8.1 | Alberton Oval |
| 1993 | Broadview | 14.7 | Kilburn | 9.17 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1994 | Kilburn | 10.15 | Port District | 8.9 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1995 | Kilburn | 14.18 | Broadview | 11.15 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1996 | Adelaide University | 21.12 | Edwardstown | 13.9 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1997 | Goodwood Saints | 11.9 | PHOS Camden | 10.8 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1998 | Broadview | 18.13 | Goodwood Saints | 8.6 | Adelaide Oval |
| 1999 | Adelaide University | 5.13 | Goodwood Saints | 5.12 | Adelaide Oval |
| 2000 | PHOS Camden | 7.5 | Broadview | 6.6 | Alberton Oval |
| 2001 | Kilburn | 19.5 | Adelaide University | 14.7 | Adelaide Oval |
| 2002 | PHOS Camden | 11.17 | Adelaide University | 10.12 | Adelaide Oval |
| 2003 | Gaza | 10.15 | Broadview | 7.9 | Adelaide Oval |
| 2004 | Broadview | 9.11 | Goodwood Saints | 8.1 | Adelaide Oval |
| 2005 | Goodwood Saints | 13.1 | Gaza | 8.5 | Adelaide Oval |
| 2006 | Goodwood Saints | 18.11 | Adelaide University | 10.12 | Alberton Oval |
| 2007 | Goodwood Saints | 19.16 | Gaza | 11.7 | Thebarton Oval |
| 2008 | Goodwood Saints | 13.9 | Salisbury North | 9.4 | Thebarton Oval |
| 2009 | Goodwood Saints | 11.13 | Henley | 8.12 | Thebarton Oval |
| 2010 | Henley | 11.6 | Sacred Heart | 7.5 | Thebarton Oval |
| 2011 | Gaza | 10.13 | Sacred Heart | 9.15 | Thebarton Oval |
| 2012 | St Peters OC | 15.13 | Henley | 13.15 | Adelaide Airport Stadium |
| 2013 | Rostrevor OC | 17.9 | Salisbury North | 10.9 | Adelaide Airport Stadium |
| 2014 | Goodwood Saints | 14.10 | Rostrevor OC | 7.7 | Adelaide Airport Stadium |
| 2015 | Goodwood Saints | 12.7 | Payneham Norwood Union | 7.9 | Adelaide Airport Stadium |
| 2016 | Prince Alfred OC | 10.13 | Tea Tree Gully | 6.10 | ALDI Arena |
